New research into workplace incident reporting suggests that organisations need to look more closely at the conditions influencing workers' decisions to report. For safety leaders and incident investigators, the findings reinforce an important principle: understand the system before judging individual behaviour.
The reporting problem may be more complex than we think
When a workplace incident goes unreported, the explanation can seem straightforward.
The worker knew the reporting requirements. They didn't report the incident. Therefore, they failed to follow the procedure.
But what if the decision was influenced by concerns about job security, relationships with colleagues, uncertainty about the reporting process, or difficulty accessing the reporting system?
A study published on 2 November 2026 offers a useful way of examining these questions.
Drawing on interviews with 34 workers in the shipbuilding and ship-repair industry, the researchers explored why workers choose to report incidents and why they sometimes remain silent.
The study identified two distinct types of barriers: threat and friction.
For organisations seeking to improve incident reporting, this distinction matters. It suggests that different barriers require different responses, and that reporting behaviour cannot be understood simply by reviewing whether a worker complied with a procedure.
Two barriers to incident reporting: threat and friction
1. Threat: What might happen if I report?
Threat refers to the consequences workers anticipate when deciding whether to report an incident.
These consequences may be formal, such as disciplinary action or perceived risks to employment. They may also be informal, involving relationships with supervisors, colleagues or work teams.
A worker might hesitate because they believe reporting could affect their reputation, create conflict within their team, or result in unwanted attention.
Importantly, the anticipated consequence does not have to occur for it to influence behaviour.
If a worker believes reporting will lead to negative treatment, that expectation may be enough to discourage them.
This raises an important question for leaders: What have workers learned from the way the organisation responds when someone reports an incident?
An organisation may have a reporting policy that encourages openness. However, the way managers respond to previous reports can influence whether workers feel comfortable using that process.
2. Friction: How difficult is it to report?
Friction refers to the practical obstacles that make reporting difficult, confusing or time-consuming.
These may include unclear reporting channels, complicated forms, limited access to reporting systems, administrative requirements or uncertainty about which events need to be reported.
Consider a worker who experiences a minor injury during a shift.
They intend to report it, but the reporting system requires access to a computer they cannot readily use. They are uncertain whether the injury meets the reporting threshold and do not know who should receive the notification.
As the shift progresses, other operational demands take priority.
The incident remains unreported.
In this example, the absence of a report does not necessarily indicate an unwillingness to report. The reporting process itself may have influenced the outcome.
An organisation can invest considerable effort in encouraging workers to speak up while overlooking whether its reporting arrangements are practical for the people expected to use them.
Reporting decisions can change over time
Another important finding from the study concerns the timing of reporting decisions.
The researchers observed that decisions about reporting are not necessarily fixed at the moment an incident occurs.
A worker may initially consider an injury insignificant. Symptoms may develop later, new information may become available, or the worker may reconsider the potential consequences of the event.
This creates an important distinction between delayed reporting and deliberate concealment.
For example, a worker experiences discomfort after a manual handling task but initially believes it will resolve. Two days later, the symptoms worsen and they notify their supervisor.
An investigation that focuses exclusively on the reporting delay may overlook the circumstances influencing the worker's initial assessment.
Investigators need to establish what the worker knew at each point, what changed, and how the reporting arrangements influenced their decisions.
This is particularly relevant when reconstructing the timeline of an incident.
Rather than treating the eventual report as the only significant point, investigators should consider the sequence of events leading to the notification.
The study is exploratory and based on a specific industry and participant group. Its findings should therefore be treated as useful insights into reporting decisions, rather than evidence of how frequently particular barriers occur across all workplaces.
What this means for ICAM investigations
The findings are particularly relevant to organisations using the Incident Cause Analysis Method (ICAM).
ICAM was developed by Gerry Gibb at BHP and is designed to examine the contributing factors behind workplace incidents, including the organisational conditions that influence individual and team actions.
A central principle of ICAM is that investigations should establish the facts, understand the conditions surrounding an event, and identify opportunities to strengthen organisational controls.
This same approach should be applied when an investigation identifies delayed or absent reporting.
Consider an investigation where an injured worker did not notify their supervisor until several days after an incident.
An investigation might identify a failure to comply with the reporting procedure. However, that observation alone does not explain the reporting decision.
Further examination may identify that the worker was uncertain about the reporting threshold, had experienced negative reactions to previous notifications, or could not access the reporting system during their shift.
These possibilities must be tested against evidence. They should not be assumed.
Applying PEEPO to reporting behaviour
Safety Wise's PEEPO approach provides a practical framework for examining the reporting environment.
Using PEEPO helps investigators identify evidence sources across the system rather than relying solely on the worker's explanation.
The information can then be used to reconstruct the timeline and assess relevant contributing factors within the ICAM framework.
Where supported by evidence, weaknesses in reporting arrangements may be identified as Organisational Factors or relevant Task/Environmental Conditions. Any classification should reflect the actual circumstances and the role those conditions played in the event being investigated.
Five questions leaders should ask about incident reporting
The research also has implications for managers and executives responsible for investigation governance.
Rather than relying exclusively on reporting statistics, leaders should examine how reporting operates in practice.
1. Do workers understand what needs to be reported? Reporting expectations should be clear, including near misses, minor injuries and events where consequences are initially uncertain.
2. Can workers report easily during normal operations? Reporting arrangements should be accessible to shift workers, contractors and employees working away from administrative facilities.
3. How do supervisors respond to reports? The initial response can influence whether workers feel comfortable raising concerns in the future.
4. What happens after a report is submitted? Workers should understand how information is assessed, what actions follow and how outcomes are communicated.
5. Are reporting delays examined fairly? Investigations should establish what influenced the delay before determining whether a procedural departure occurred and what corrective actions are appropriate.
These questions can support reporting system reviews, investigation quality assessments and ICAM governance discussions.
They also provide an opportunity to distinguish between reporting requirements that exist on paper and arrangements that function effectively in daily operations.
Improving reporting requires attention to both barriers
The distinction between threat and friction offers a useful way for organisations to review their reporting arrangements.
Where threat is identified, attention may need to focus on management responses, confidentiality, fair and just culture practices, and the consequences workers reasonably expect when raising concerns.
Where friction is identified, improvements may involve clearer reporting criteria, simpler notification processes, accessible reporting channels or better guidance for supervisors.
The response should match the evidence.
A reporting process that is easy to use may still be avoided if workers expect negative consequences. Equally, a supportive workplace culture cannot fully compensate for a reporting system that workers struggle to access or understand.
The research also indicates that factors encouraging reporting are not necessarily the direct opposite of factors discouraging it. This is an important consideration when designing improvement initiatives.
The Safety Wise perspective: investigate the reporting environment
Incident reporting is an important source of information for organisational learning.
When incidents are not reported, organisations may miss opportunities to identify deteriorating controls, recurring hazards or weaknesses in their systems of work.
The quality of reporting information also influences the quality of subsequent investigations.
Safety Wise's ICAM approach encourages investigators to look beyond individual actions and examine the conditions that influenced those actions.
This principle applies equally to the decision to report an incident.
For leaders, the practical lesson is to examine whether reporting arrangements support the behaviours the organisation expects.
For investigators, it is to distinguish evidence from assumptions and ensure that findings are supported by a proper examination of the reporting environment.
When a worker does not report an incident, the investigation should ask why the reporting system did not produce the expected outcome.
That question may reveal opportunities for improvement that a finding of non-compliance would otherwise miss.
Research reference
Wonders, M. E., Haygood, A., Jang, H., Kaplan, S. A., & Frerichs, V. (2026). How Safety Incident Reporting Decisions Are Made: A Multilevel, Process-Oriented Perspective. Occupational Health Science, 10, Article 36. Published 2 November 2026.
Read the open-access research on Springer Nature
Editorial note: The article uses “threat and friction” as a practical way to discuss reporting barriers. These are not presented as the study's complete formal thematic framework. The workplace examples and ICAM applications are Safety Wise interpretations of the research, rather than findings directly tested by the researchers.

